Representing The Craft – in the Media

Yeah, it is me, being sarcastic again. It is painful to see which pieces/makers the magazines pick to represent our Craft. No offense to anyone who showed up there – I am not saying all featured makers are bad choices. I was there too, and some of my respected fellow makers, but they make some pretty miserable choices as well. How? Let me illustrate:

In a parallel situation, allow me to introduce Mr. ……..*, from ……… ** who started his English studies last week (my English is not that great as well, so I hope nobody takes it as an offense. I could have picked pottery*** too), but already succeeded to write down his own name + 2 whole sentence, with only 5 mistakes! Here they are:

“I em ….., fromm …. I lice reiding and lerning. Where is the postofis?

He sad he is only in the beginning of his career, but we are pretty sure that he will be successful as he practices this rare language! We are all amazed by the talent, he put together those words and composed those wonderful sentences. We must say: we need to keep an eye on this guy – he might be the future Shakespeare! 

Don’t misunderstand me – I have no problem beginners being featured in magazines. I think that is a great thing. They need chances to get their names out there, it is perfectly fine and right. Just as beginner musicians should have a chance to show their skills, have a performance.

My problem is way more specific: it is not about ONE person being promoted, it is about REPRESENTATION. When they claim an up and coming shoemaker (or actually any craftsmen) for being a “professional” whereas their work.. well, is not. When a maker is picked to be featured, that is a responsibility. If s/he is presented as frontrunner of the craft, what will readers think about the rest of craft community? In  good cases, they will not believe that our work is really handmade, since they know about the best makers and their work don’t look like that, right? It happened many times with me. Sometimes I get a well intended compliment, that my shoes look like factory made ones, but in the worst case, they just think that the work is factory made and I am just a shoe store owner, and I call myself shoemaker to make it sound fancy. (I wouldn’t be the first in history, hmm?)

I feel that shoemaking is very poorly represented in media. People tend to believe that shoemakers don’t make fine work, only “crafty” shoes with funny materials and all of them started to learn the craft a year ago as a sole flame holder of a dying tradition, in whom we have to put all our hopes. Well, the truth is: shoemaking is getting more and more popular, getting further and further away from dying. Besides a lot of enthusiastic beginners, who I hope will have a lot of chances to be in magazines, TV shows, etc., there are more experienced craftsmen, who can create professional looking work. Please talk about those – us – too.

Before I left Hungary, the last year I refused all the media requests, interviews, etc. Why? I got fed up with the picture they want to show: “dying craft”, “last shoemaker” etc. – if they don’t bother to do their homework, why would I help their job? Here in the States I gave some interviews, but I tend to think that I will do the same – at times media does bigger damage than help. 

__________

*  I did want just to pick some name – there are several thousand people read this, so someone would have been pissed. I hope nobody is called Mr. Dot Dot Dot.

** same here

***I am miserable in pottery – maybe because I have never tried.

8 thoughts on “Representing The Craft – in the Media”

  1. Hi Marcell,

    I always enjoy your rants. They are always on point. The problem you face is that you think magazine writers are trying to represent the craft. But in reality, magazine writers are trying to sell magazines. A lot of times the stories they write are the most convenient. This friend know that novice shoemaker who is selling these shoes to that celebrity and isn’t it amazing. To take the time to understand the craft and find the real experts is too time consuming. I wouldn’t be surprised if the trendy novice shoemaker has approached the magazine with the story idea. That’s more like it. Easy and sells magazines.

    1. I agree with Vonallentx’s reply, and Marcell, if you continue to refuse interviews you are giving them less accurate content to write write about.
      You could always send them my way if you do not want to be written about. I’ll take the exposure. 😉

  2. I think it is very annoying, that all you do on your blog is complain about other people… seriously, every other post. Extremely tiring and a testament of very poor character….

    1. Everyone loves a train wreck. It’s the nature of the internet. For someone who loves to criticize others you certainly have a thin skin.

      1. ^^All True craftsmen are professional complainers. Find me one old school master craftsman who skips through life with giddy prose and I’ll show you a pair of his shitty shoes.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.